Cases / NAD v. Netflix

National Ass'n of the Deaf (NAD) v. Netflix

A seminal 2012 ruling that confirmed the ADA applies to streaming services, solidifying the legal requirement for captioning on digital-only content platforms.

Case Background

The National Association of the Deaf (NAD) filed a lawsuit against Netflix in 2010, arguing that the lack of closed captions on the majority of Netflix's streaming content violated the ADA. The plaintiffs asserted that because Netflix was a "place of public accommodation," it had a legal obligation to provide equal access to its services for people who are deaf or hard of hearing.

At the time, Netflix argued that, as an internet-only service without a physical store, it was not covered by the ADA.

Filed 2010, District of Massachusetts

The Central Argument

The central legal question was whether the ADA applies to purely "virtual" or internet-only businesses that have no physical location open to the public.

  • Is a subscription streaming service considered a "place of public accommodation" under the ADA?
  • Does the ADA mandate closed captioning for all streamed videos, regardless of their original broadcast format?

The Binding Settlement and Precedent (2012)

The court denied Netflix's motion to dismiss, finding that the ADA **does** apply to services offered exclusively online. Netflix subsequently settled the case.

Netflix agreed to provide closed captions on 100% of its content by 2014, establishing a massive precedent that digital-only streaming services are fully covered by the ADA, significantly impacting the entertainment industry.

STREAMING
IS COVERED

Established digital-only services are subject to ADA compliance.

Compliance Takeaway for Your Business

This case is critical for any organization operating **purely online**. It eliminated the "physical location" defense, making it clear that services like online education, subscription software, and streaming media must fully comply with accessibility requirements, particularly captioning (for video content).

Need guidance on ADA compliance?
We're available.